By KEVIN FREKING,
Associated Press Writer August 23, 2005
WASHINGTON - Obesity rates
rose last year in every state but Oregon, according
to an advocacy group that called on the government
and the private sector to get more involved in
Americans' battle with expanding waistlines.
The advocacy group, Trust for
America's Health, said data from the Centers for
Disease Control and Prevention showed that the
percentage of obese adults for 2002-04 stood at
22.7 percent nationally. The percentage for the
previous cycle, 2001-03, was 22 percent.
The state exhibiting the
largest increase in obesity was Alabama. There, the
rate increased 1.5 percentage points to 27.7
percent. Oregon's rate held steady at 21
percent.
The report said the states
with the highest percentage of obese adults are
Mississippi, Alabama, West Virginia, Louisiana and
Tennessee.
The states with the lowest
percentage of obese adults are Colorado,
Massachusetts, Rhode Island, Connecticut, Vermont
and Montana. Hawaii was not included in the
report.
An official with the Trust
for America's Health said the United States is
stuck in a "debate limbo" about how the government
should confront obesity. She used the report to
call for more government action on several fronts,
such as ensuring that land use plans promote
physical activity; that school lunch programs serve
healthier meals; and that Medicaid recipients get
access to subsidized fitness programs, such as
aerobics classes at the local YMCA.
"We have a crisis of poor
nutrition and physical inactivity in the U.S., and
it's time we dealt with it," said Shelley A.
Hearne, executive director of the
organization.
Radley Balko, a policy
analyst at the Cato Institute, said he is wary of
the call for more government action on obesity. The
institute is a think tank that prefers free-market
approaches to problems.
"I think obesity is a very
personal issue. What you eat and how often you
exercise, if that comes within the government's
purview, it's difficult to think of what's left
that isn't," Balko said.
Health policy analysts
maintain that obesity increases the burden on
taxpayers because it requires the Medicare and
Medicaid programs to cover the treatment of
diseases caused by obesity. The report issued
Tuesday said taxpayers spent $39 billion in 2003
for the treatment of conditions attributable to
obesity.
The Trust for America's
Health recommended mandatory screening for obesity
among Medicaid recipients, as well as nutritional
counseling.
"Better prevention and
disease management programs will result in cost
savings to the system as a whole," the report
stated.
Balko said it's not clear the
government really knows how to persuade people to
make better decisions. He said open-ended
entitlement programs, such as Medicaid and
Medicare, don't provide much of a financial
incentive for people to watch their weight. The
government just picks up the cost of treating
diseases for those patients, regardless of the
amounts, he said.
He prefers that the
government give Medicaid and Medicare recipients an
incentive to open medical savings accounts, which
would allow them to save money when they did not
access the health care system.
"If they knew they only had
so much to spend, or what they did not spend could
be saved, then maybe you could instill a certain
sense of responsibility and ownership," Balko
said.
Adults with a body mass index
of 30 or more are considered obese. The equation
used to figure body mass index is body weight in
kilograms divided by height in meters squared. The
measurement is not a good indicator of obesity for
muscular people who exercise a lot.
__
On the Net:
Trust for America's Health:
http://www.healthyamericans.org